Zach Werenski has emerged as the clear frontrunner for the 2025-26 James Norris Memorial Trophy after being named a finalist alongside Cale Makar and Rasmus Dahlin on May 7. The Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman posted another strong all-around campaign, leading his team in scoring for the second straight year while excelling at five-on-five and in defensive metrics, building on his runner-up finish to Makar last season. Makar, a two-time winner seeking a third Norris, remains a top contender thanks to his offensive impact with the Avalanche but trails in the current trader consensus. Dahlin earned his first finalist nod after anchoring Buffalo’s improved standings and playoff return, yet his lower implied probability reflects a more competitive field where Werenski’s consistent production and recent poll leadership have solidified market positioning.