**Poor audience reception, evidenced by a rare D+ CinemaScore and dismal critic scores, drives the overwhelming trader consensus that "Other Mommy" will earn under $10 million in its second weekend.** The Blumhouse horror film, starring Jessica Chastain and based on Josh Malerman’s novel, delivered a solid $27.5 million opening despite mixed genre tracking, but its steep projected drop—analysts anticipate at least 70%—mirrors recent underperformers like "Verity." Horror titles often front-load business, and with weak word-of-mouth spreading quickly, the second-weekend hold appears limited against typical mid-October competition. An upset above $10 million would require unusually strong retention or minimal new releases, scenarios traders view as improbable given the confirmed audience rejection.