**"Ice Cream Man," Eli Roth’s unrated horror-comedy released in wide theatrical release on August 7, 2026, has opened to overwhelmingly negative critical reception.** The Tomatometer currently sits in the high 20s to low 30s percent range (29–31% across 70–93 reviews), with an average rating near 3.9/10 and a Metacritic score of 35/100. Critics have faulted the film’s thin plot, uneven tone, and reliance on excessive gore without substantive payoff, comparing it unfavorably to Roth’s stronger recent work like “Thanksgiving.” The score stabilized quickly after release because early reviews from major outlets and horror-focused sites converged on middling-to-poor assessments, with many individual scores at 3/10 or below. Audience metrics remain sparse (fewer than 50 verified ratings on RT), but initial social and box-office tracking suggest limited mainstream appeal beyond genre fans. With the bulk of critic reviews already aggregated and the film’s campaign focused on unrated splatter rather than awards or prestige positioning, the current consensus points to a final score unlikely to climb significantly. Any late positive outliers could nudge the percentage modestly, but historical patterns for similar mid-budget horror releases indicate the number will hold in the low-30s range absent a dramatic reevaluation.