**Early critic reactions to the Will Gluck-directed romantic comedy have produced a mixed 52% Tomatometer score on Rotten Tomatoes from roughly two dozen reviews (average 5.4/10), with Metacritic at 40/100, establishing a baseline of tempered expectations ahead of the August 7 wide release.** The film, starring Monica Barbaro and Callum Turner as strangers navigating love during a fictionalized “one night only” event in New York, benefits from strong lead chemistry and Gluck’s track record with crowd-pleasing entries like *Anyone but You*. However, several critics note the premise starts edgy before softening into conventional, safe territory. Audience and additional critic scores will likely shift after the premiere screenings and opening weekend, when streaming metrics, word-of-mouth, and box-office tracking become clearer signals for traders. Historical patterns for mid-budget studio rom-coms show scores often stabilize within a narrow range once 50–75 reviews are in, making the next 48–72 hours the key window for momentum changes.